Best Miata Soft Top Replacement In 2021: Reviews & Buying Guide

Soft tops are a blessing for convertible drivers. You can take it off when you want to relish the weather and put it on when the sun becomes unbearable or the rain starts pouring down. You can imagine what the best soft top for Mazda Miata does for you if you drive a Mazda Miata. Are you looking for the best Miata soft top replacement? Then, we can be of help!

If you are in a hurry and want to skip right to our best pick, we would advise you to go for the Mazda Miata Stayfast cover from Sierra Auto Tops. It comes in a premium cloth, which is an upgrade over the existing top fabric of your convertible. Also, it is incredibly long-lasting. You won’t have to think about buying another Miata top in the foreseeable future.  

Mazda Miata convertibles would rank among the most popular cars in our era. Nonetheless, you would be surprised to notice that there are not many high-quality options when you are trying to buy a Mazda Miata soft top replacement. We have gone through the best Miata soft top reviews to produce the list of best Miata soft top replacement recommendations. 

So, without further ado, let’s get started with the reviews!

Best Miata Soft Top Replacement: Top 10 Recommendations

Insert WordPress Content

1. Soft Top Replacements for Mazda Miata (Sierra Auto Tops)

Insert WordPress Content

Auto Tops Direct, a company that provides luxury convertible accessories to its clientele, offers the Sierra series of convertible soft tops. This edition, designed for the Mazda Miata, is one of their bestseller products, thanks to its several appealing traits. The top adds both artistic merit and comfort to the overall driving experience.

Quick Summary

The top is made of black Stayfast cloth and has glass heated windows. This roof is an OEM-grade replacement for Mazda Miatas. The rain guard secures the edges of the tops and prevents water from getting inside the car. A new DOT-approved tinted glass window with integrated defroster wiring is also a part of the package. 

Why Is It A Top Pick? 

Black Stayfast is one of the most trustworthy fabrics for convertible tops. Because of its incredibly durable material, this Sierra Auto Tops roof deserves to be in the best aftermarket soft top for Miata debate. This is a top that has been made for demanding applications. The manufacturer has used the finest strands of polyester to use it. 

Our Thoughts

The fabric is beautiful and smooth, and in our honest opinion, it looks way nicer than vinyl. Vinyl tops tend to get overly tight in colder weather. So, this one will save you from that hassle. The installation isn’t challenging at all! It comes with guidelines, and it’s easier to set up than other tops.

Pros
  • Durable.
  • Soft and comfy.
  • Made with automated machinery for precise measurement.
  • Easy to set up.
Cons
  • The pre-punched holes don’t perfectly align with the mounting points.

2. Autoberry Mazda Miata Convertible Top

Insert WordPress Content

If you have a vintage Mazda Miata lying around in your garage, then this Mazda Miata convertible top could be the best pick for you. This is a convertible top from Autoberry for Mazda Miata models that come out between 1989 and 2005. Autoberry produces top-of-the-line convertible accessories for Mazda Miata and other cars.

Quick Summary

Autoberry gives you the option to customize the roof color to match the color of your vehicle. Therefore, it doesn’t feel like an aftermarket roof. It is built to Mazda’s specifications. So, you won’t have much of a pertinent issue. It uses Cabrio vinyl, which is arguably the best convertible top material. Also, it has 40 gauge DOT-approved windows.

Why Is This A Top Pick?

As we have studied the best Miata soft top replacement reviews online, we noticed how much retro Miata owners love this top. It uses Cabrio, like the original Mazda Miata top, so it brings a sense of authenticity. Autoberry has insulated the top with a UV-resistant coating to keep the vinyl from cracking. In addition to that, it stops mold and mildew buildup.

Our Thoughts

For newbies, the installation can take a while. But once you got that out of the way, you would find out how great of a convertible top it is. It looks shiny and gorgeous. The top is really tight fitting and appears to be a lot more expensive than it actually is. We took it out in the rain and washed it in a car wash-there were no leaks whatsoever.

Pros
  • Uses Cabrio vinyl, which is the original top material of Mazda Miata cars.
  • Accurate fit.
  • Fits older Miata models.
  • Color variations.
Cons
  • The installation might take more time than you would’ve expected.

3. Soft Top Replacements for Mazda Miata MX5 (Sierra Auto Tops)

Insert WordPress Content

This convertible soft top for Mazda Miata MX5 automobiles produced between 1990 and 2005 is another consumer-favorite Sierra Auto Tops offering. It has many of the same distinguishing characteristics as the first Sierra top we talked about. The most significant factor that differentiates the two is the material.

Quick Summary

As we have just said, this top has a different material than the one we previously reviewed. Instead of Stayfast fabric, this top sticks to the classic Cabrio vinyl. It comes in a single unit, in contrast to Miata’s original two-piece style. Therefore, it is compatible with Miata models ranging from 1990 to 2005, whereas the OEM top only fits 1989 to 1997 models.

Why Is This A Top Pick?

This silky smooth top features 38 ounces of Cabrio Vinyl, which makes the top exceptionally soft. But, it’s also pretty durable since Cabrio outlasts regular cloth. It also has a glossy appearance and a gritty plastic feeling. This replacement will seem more authentic on your convertible because it is made of the same material as the original Mazda Miata soft tops.

Our Thoughts

Since this is an economy version, we had our doubts while testing it, but we must say that it has won us over with its extraordinary features. The quality is excellent for the price. Putting up the top is quite simple. The secret is to follow the steps in the correct order, and it will be all set in no time.

Pros
  • Similar to the original Miata top.
  • Affordable.
  • Shiny appearance.
  • Heat-sealed window.
Cons
  • The rear window might pick up scratches easily.

4. Mazda Miata Convertible Top From Autoberry

Insert WordPress Content

This Autoberry top is another suitable fit for the 1990-2005 Mazda Miatas. It would be a nice substitute to consider if you don’t want the new top to seem too much different from the original. Autoberry used Cabrio grain vinyl to make the top more akin to the factory edition. Cabrio vinyl is effective in minimizing the detrimental impacts of rough weather.

Quick Summary

The Autoberry Miata convertible top has a one-piece construction with deck seams and overlapping quarter panels. To make it easier to set up, Autoberry has included pre-punched plastic retainers. It works with all Miata models that launched between the years 1990 and 2005. 

Why Is It A Top Pick?

The build quality of this top is so impressive that it would hold up to some extreme weather conditions. The manufacturer cut it using state-of-the-art technology to guarantee precision fitting. Besides the traditional black, you also have the option to buy it in tan color. Furthermore, the top features DOT-approved glass windows with defroster wires.

Our Thoughts

Without a doubt, this top is of exceptional quality and comparable to any of the more expensive ones. It exhibits top-notch craftsmanship and fits the frame of the car superbly. It comes with all of the essential holes to align with a rain rail, as well as rivet holes for the frame. The top can tolerate a heavy storm. We also love how easy it is to clean.

Pros
  • Weather-resistant.
  • Affordable.
  • Perfect fit.
  • Easy to wash.
Cons
  • Feels a bit tight at first, but the fabric relaxes after getting regular sun exposure.

5. Soft Top Replacements for Mazda Miata MX5

Insert WordPress Content

The fifth entry in our best Miata soft top replacement list is this light tan top from Sierra Auto Tops. Due to its very unique color, your convertible will attract extra attention on the road! Since its material is Cabrio vinyl, which is the same as the original Miata tops, the authenticity of the car will remain intact upon installing it.

Quick Summary

This top is of the same quality as the OEM Miata tops. A deck seam runs down each side of the top deck. Heat is used to seal all seams. Two-layer stitching reinforces the seams for further strength and stability. The Cabrio vinyl material brings the ingenuity of an authentic Miata top.

Why Is It A Top Pick?

The best Miata soft top reviews say that this item closely resembles the OEM Miata tops. Since it has that feel of originality, we couldn’t overlook it for our top ten selection. This top is identical with the top that comes with Miata convertibles in terms of weight and grain amount. 

Our Thoughts

We love the exotic light tan color the top comes in. It fits well, and the rear window has good visibility. The installation is not difficult. You can get hold of it by watching a tutorial video on YouTube. We are also satisfied with the sewing quality. The seams are highly functional, so you don’t need additional sewing to make them durable.

Pros
  • Resembles original Miata tops in quality.
  • Beautiful light tan color.
  • Durable.
  • High-visibility window.
Cons
  • Some users reported that the window comes off after a few months.

6. Autoberry Mazda Miata Convertible Top [Attached Rain Guard]

Insert WordPress Content

Heat-sealed seams on this Miata top maintain a cozy temperature inside the convertible. The hot air outside will not replace the cold air inside or vice versa. On top of that, it comes with a pre-attached rain guard. So, you won’t have to pay extra for installing rain guards. It’s part of the package.

Quick Summary

The top is a 38 ounce Cabrio vinyl sheet which makes it considerably heavy-duty.  With built-in defroster wiring, the DOT-certified windows block a decent amount of sun and keep the car atmosphere comfortable.  A PVC rain rail runs along the seams to keep the car interior safe from rainfall.

Why Is It A Top Pick? 

The pre-installed rain rail is a huge advantage. The price is very reasonable considering the separate purchase and installation cost of the rain guard. The premium polyester thread stitching makes the top highly resilient to mold and mildew growth. Autoberry’s advanced cutting process allows for pinpoint measurements.

Our Thoughts

We believe the embedded rain rail makes the item exceptionally convenient. To most of us, putting up the top is a hassle itself. Installing the rain rail is an extra shift of work, and this top relieves you of that inconvenience. The quality of the rain rail is pretty good. Overall, this a great purchase for 1990-2005 Miatas.

Pros
  • Pre-installed rain rail.
  • Clear window.
  • Retains ideal in-car temperature.
  • Durable.
Cons
  • You can’t use the defroster glass without buying a separate wire connector.

7. Autoberry Convertible Top for Mazda Miata [Cabrio Vinyl Cover]

Insert WordPress Content

This is a Cabrio vinyl cover for more recent Mazda models. This one might seem familiar because it shares a lot of similarities with the first item in our best Mazda Miata reviews article. Both of them are black and fit the same Miata models. But, this one is Cabrio-made, whereas the other one has a Stayfast top. They also come from different manufacturers. 

Quick Summary

The first-grade Cabrio vinyl material makes the top immune to fungus infestations. The window provides excellent visibility and comes DOT-approved. Therefore, it remarkably keeps the harmful sun rays outside the car and lets in the right amount to liven up the car atmosphere. Heat-sealed seams keep out the sweltering summer heat and the biting winter cold.

Why Is It A Top Pick?

This top matches Mazda Miata MX5 2006-2015 specs to perfection. The DOT-certified window regulates the amount of sunshine that enters your car. It doesn’t come with a rain rail, but the seams provide an excellent level of weather resistance on their own. The color of the fabric withstands heavy sun and rain. So, it won’t fade prematurely.

Our Thoughts

Based on our personal experience and the reviews we read online, we can say without any hesitation that this top is a perfect fit for the cars it’s meant for. You won’t find water or outside air leaking through the top. The defroster works perfectly. Autoberry delivered a fantastic convertible top on a budget.

Pros
  • Ultra-durable seams.
  • Great price.
  • Authentic look.
  • Doesn’t fade easily.
Cons
  • Not the easiest convertible top to install.

8. Autoberry Mazda Miata Convertible Top With Attached Rain Guard

Insert WordPress Content

Autoberry has designed this top in a one-piece style to match the tops we see in recent MX5 cars. It’s suitable for all Miata convertibles that hit the market from 1990 to 2005. The top is also fit for glass window convertibles. Because of its design, it costs less than the factory-style two-piece roof, but it offers the same level of functionality.

Quick Summary

The highlight of this top is the flexible rail guard that lasts for a long time. Because of its tensile properties, it doesn’t crack to pressure. The Cabrio vinyl top mimics the OEM Mazda Miata roofs in both appearance and performance. You can use some parts of the old convertible top while installing this one.

Why Is It A Top Pick?

The top features high-quality Cabrio vinyl, which makes for a plush feel. It doesn’t make much noise. In fact, it’s one of the quietest tops we have reviewed here. The window is crystal clear. Unlike the original one, you can’t unzip it, but it effortlessly creases down with the top. The rain rail is very effective and durable.

Our Thoughts

The rain rail works very well, but it presents some fitting issues. The stud hole punch is not in the right position between the rail and the top. It's not a major concern, however. You can cut off the extra cloth and find the perfect alignment. Other than that, this top ticks all the right boxes.

Pros
  • Premium feel.
  • Durable.
  • Clear windows with DOT approval for sun protection.
  • Pre-installed rain rail.
Cons
  • You have to trim off some extra material to set up the top properly.

9. Soft Top Replacements for Mazda Miata MX5 1990-2005

Insert WordPress Content

This Soft Auto Tops roof recreates the genuine aesthetic of 1990-2005 Miata tops. For added utility, Soft Auto Tops has incorporated a rain rail in its design. It's made to go over your Miata's factory components and fit over existing frames in an instant. For this reason, you can consider this item as a factory-grade soft top replacement for Miata.

Quick Summary

It has a one-piece construction that can replace vintage OEM two-piece Miata roofs. It also fits a wider range of cars, compared to the original roof. The plastic window deflects harmful UV rays. Also, it accounts for an unobstructed view. Auto Tops has heat-sealed the window to make sure it stays in place over time.  

Why Is It A Top Pick?

This top broke into the list with its superior build quality and performance. The durable Cabrio fabric enables a quieter car interior. The window comes heat sealed for better insulation. Therefore, you can drive with the same comfort in winter as you do in summer. The rain rail fortifies the seams and stops rainwater from getting inside.

Our Thoughts

The top feels very tight while installing, but we would say it makes the top more resilient and makes it more stubborn against strong wind. We love the rain rail. We had the chance to put it on its mettle as we drove through a heavy drizzle. It passed with flying colors. The top high scores were high in heat insulation as well.

Pros
  • Rain guard included.
  • Superb heat insulation.
  • The window has clear visibility.
  • Durable.
Cons
  • The top is difficult to stretch. So, installing it would be quite burdensome.

10. Soft Top Replacements for Mazda Miata MX5 2006-2015

Insert WordPress Content

In our final Mazda Miata soft top review, we will take a look at this Sierra Auto Tops top that uses Stayfast in place of conventional vinyl. Many users prefer Steadfast over regular vinyl as it's less prone to wrinkling and cracking. Moreover, Stayfast tops can operate quieter than their vinyl counterparts.

Quick Summary

AutoTops has used beige Haartz StayFast fabric to make this top. It has also used similar colored polyester threads for stitching. The window has integrated defroster wiring and DOT certification. AutoTops secured the seams with heat treatment for enhanced sturdiness and heat insulation. 

Why Is This A Top Pick? 

It’s a top pick because of its high-end fabric, prolonged lifespan, and outstanding performance. The seams are sewn with high-quality polyester fibers. On top of it, there is a rain guard to provide extra protection. The beige color stays intact until the top wears out. It doesn’t flap in the wind and remains taut as you drive.

Our Thoughts

We felt the installation was simple in comparison to other tops. It stays tight while driving, but it stretches comfortably in all directions when we put it on, thanks to the glorious Stayfast fabric. The insulation is as good as you can ask for. It keeps the interior car temperature pleasant in all seasons.

Pros
  • Long-lasting.
  • Don't get discolored soon.
  • Flexible but doesn’t flap in the wind.
  • Pre-installed rain guard.
Cons
  • You might need to cut it a bit for proper installation.

How To Choose The Best Miata Soft Top Replacement?


How Much Does It Cost To Replace a Miata Soft Top?


The replacement cost depends on factors like fabric quality, rain guard, window type, precision fit, etc. Premium options might set you off around a thousand bucks, whereas you would find lots of cheaper but good enough alternatives for only a couple of hundred. If you want professional installation, it would cost you $100/$200 more.

How to Remove Miata Soft Top?

The first thing you would need to do is to detach the driver’s seat from the car. After that, shift your attention towards the carpet buttons and the metal rail that supports the top. Remove them and slowly pull the top away.

How To Install Miata Soft Top?

After taking your old top off, drape the new top over the top frame. Find the attachment strings on either side of the new top and secure them to the frame using it. Once you do that, put back the metal rail and put on the weather stripping afterward. Finally, attach the back of the top with the car with hex nuts. 

How Long Does A Convertible Top Last?

The best soft top for Mazda Miata can stay in its best shape for five to seven years. You can hope to extend its service life by taking proper care of it. Substandard convertible tops might scratch and tear within months.

How To Adjust Miata Soft Top?

Locate the hexagonal screw that is used to adjust the clasp on the top. It should feature a locking clip to stop the top from moving out of its current position. Turn the screw to the desired setting after releasing the plastic clasp with your fingernails.

How To Clean Miata Soft Top?

Remove dirt and debris from the convertible top with a soft brush. Then, soak the top in a non-abrasive detergent solution. If you didn’t wash the top for a while, then brush it a bit more. Afterward, rinse it thoroughly in clean water so that no detergent or grime gets left behind.

How To Replace Miata Soft Top?

Once your Miata top wears out, you should buy a high-quality aftermarket replacement for it. Before buying, do some research and see what attributes you should consider for ensuring you get a high-quality top. Look at the fabric quality, the window style, its visibility and UV-blocking capabilities, and seam quality to find the best roof for your convertible.

Frequently Asked Questions


Q. Can I Install A Miata Soft Top Myself? 

Installing a Miata top would take you around eight hours. If you’ve never installed a convertible top before, it might take you a bit longer. But, it is possible to install a Miata soft top all by yourself. 

Q. What Do DOT-Approved Windows Mean?

DOT is the abbreviation for the United States Department of Transportation. Without complying with DOT standards, your windows will not have ample visibility and will put you at a higher risk of accidents.

Q.  Can I Use Soft Tops In Winter?

You won’t face any problems using soft tops in winter. On the contrary, a quality soft top can keep the interior of your car warm and cozy during winter. That said, you should avoid soft tops with plastic windows because plastic tends to crack in lower temperatures. Check the top for any openings that could allow snow to enter the vehicle.

Final Words

Mazda Miata convertibles would rank among the most popular cars in our era. Nonetheless, you would be surprised to notice that there are not many high-quality options when you are trying to buy a Mazda Miata soft top replacement. 

We hope our buying guide on the best Miata Soft Top Replacement was helpful to you. If you have any more questions, don’t hesitate to ask!

Happy Shopping! 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *